2.3 - Protestant Reform Continues
The Protestant Reformation: Key Ingredients and Impacts
- Key Ingredients for a Religious Reformation:
- Reformist Zeal: A strong desire for reform within the church.
- Church Corruption: Corruption within the Catholic Church, providing the need for reform.
- Pre-Reformation Reformers:
- John Wycliffe (14th Century): Attempted to reform the Catholic Church in England.
- Jan Hus (15th Century): Sought to eliminate corruption within the church.
- Both attacked the Church’s wealth and taught that the Bible, not the pope, was the highest authority. Wycliffe’s followers made the first complete English translation of the Bible (copied by hand), and Hus was burned at the stake at the Council of Constance in 1415. Without printing, their ideas spread slowly and stayed mostly local (in England and Bohemia).
- Neither Wycliffe nor Hus had the same widespread impact as Martin Luther.
- The Role of the Printing Press:
- Impact on Luther's Reforms:
- The printing press was a crucial tool that allowed Martin Luther's ideas to spread widely across Europe.
- Luther wrote in simple, punchy German, not only in scholarly Latin. His short pamphlets were cheap and quick to print, and printers all over Germany rushed to reprint them because they sold so well.
- Woodcut pictures and cartoons (many from the workshop of Luther’s friend, the painter Lucas Cranach) mocked the pope, so even people who could not read got the message. Pamphlets were also read aloud in homes, taverns, and town squares.
- Effect: Thousands of copies spread faster than the Church could ban them, so Luther could not be silenced the way Hus had been. Protestant ideas reached every social class and became permanently established in much of northern Europe.
- It fundamentally altered the religious landscape, unlike any prior reform efforts.
- Vernacular Bibles:
- Luther argued for the Bible to be translated into German (vernacular language), making it accessible to the common people.
- Luther did much of this work himself. While hiding at Wartburg Castle, he began translating the Bible into German. His translation came out in parts starting in 1522, and the complete Bible appeared in 1534. It became a best seller and helped standardize the written German language.
- Before this, the Church’s official Bible was the Latin Vulgate, and the Mass was said in Latin. A few earlier translations existed, but they were rare and expensive, so most ordinary people relied on priests to tell them what the Bible said.
- The spread of vernacular Bibles posed a significant threat to the Catholic Church's authority.
- Spread of Vernacular Bibles:
- By 1523, the New Testament was translated into French, and by 1526, an English version was available.
- Despite efforts by Catholic authorities to suppress these translations, the printing press ensured their wide distribution.
- Challenge to Church and State Authority:
- The Protestant Church of England (Anglican Church):
- Established by King Henry VIII, primarily to secure a divorce that the Catholic Church would not grant.
- The Anglican Church was initially similar to the Catholic Church, leading to further reform efforts by the Puritans under Elizabeth I.
- Puritans and the English Civil War:
- The Puritans, influenced by Calvinism, sought to remove lingering Catholic practices in the Church of England.
- Their efforts led to conflict with the Stuart monarchs, resulting in the English Civil War, where the Puritans emerged victorious.
- Anabaptists and the Separation of Church and State:
- Anabaptists believed in a strict separation of church and state.
- They refused military service based on religious convictions, asserting that their spiritual obligations took precedence over secular commitments.
- Calvin and Church Independence in Geneva:
- In most Lutheran lands, the prince ran the church, so the state stood above the church. Calvin rejected this. He argued that the church must govern itself through its own pastors and lay elders, not through a prince or city council.
- In Geneva, the church’s Consistory (pastors and elders) disciplined people for sins like drunkenness, gambling, and skipping church. Calvin fought the city council for years over who could excommunicate someone (ban them from communion), and in 1555 he won: the church, not the city government, held that power.
- This self-governing model (later called Presbyterian church government) gave Calvinist churches in France, Scotland, and the Netherlands their own organization outside the king’s control, which made them very hard for rulers to crush.
- Religious Conflict as a Reason to Resist Kings:
- Most rulers believed a kingdom should have one church, controlled by the crown (“one king, one faith, one law”). When subjects held a different faith, religion gave them a reason to challenge the king’s control of the church, and sometimes the king himself.
- Huguenots (France): French Calvinists built their own churches outside the king’s Catholic church. After the St. Bartholomew’s Day Massacre (1572), Huguenot writers argued that nobles and other lesser officials had the right to resist a king who persecuted true religion (see 2.4).
- Puritans (England): Puritans rejected the bishops and rituals that Elizabeth I and the Stuart kings kept in the Church of England, which led to the conflict above.
- Nobles in Poland: Polish nobles who became Lutheran or Calvinist used their strong political rights to protect their churches. In the Warsaw Confederation (1573), they made future kings promise to keep religious peace among nobles of different faiths.
- The Printing Press as a Catalyst:
- The printing press was the "spiciest ingredient" in the Reformation, spreading ideas that reshaped both the religious and political fabric of Europe.
