4.6 - Expanding Democracy
Greater Equality
Alexis de Tocqueville's Observations:
- Social Interaction: People of all classes ate together and traveled together, making class distinctions less apparent.
- Equality of Opportunity: The belief that any White male could rise in society through talent and hard work was prevalent.
- "Self-Made Man": Celebrated in American culture, though women did not share in this ideal due to legal and cultural restrictions.
Politics of the Common Man
Between 1824 and 1840, American politics became more inclusive, involving middle- and lower-class citizens.
Factors Contributing to Democratic Spread:
- New Suffrage Laws: Expanded voting rights to all White males, removing property and religious qualifications.
- Changes in Political Parties and Campaigns: Increased popular participation and voter turnout.
- Improved Education and Newspaper Circulation: Informed more citizens about political issues.
- Why It Happened: Revolutionary ideas about equality made property requirements look unfair. New Western states, eager for settlers, gave the vote to all white men, which pressured older Eastern states to drop their property rules too. The market revolution also created many wage earners in cities who owned no land but wanted a voice.
Universal White Male Suffrage:
- Western States' Constitutions: Indiana, Illinois, and Missouri allowed all White males to vote and hold office, influencing other states to follow.
- Dorr Rebellion (1841-1842): Rhode Island still used its 1663 colonial charter, which let only landowners vote, so many working men couldn't vote. Thomas Dorr led a "People's Convention" that wrote a new constitution, and his supporters elected him governor of a rival government in 1842. The rebellion collapsed, but Rhode Island soon adopted a new constitution (1843) that let far more men vote.
- Limits: Expanded suffrage was for white men only. As states dropped property requirements for white men, several took the vote away from free Black men: New York kept a $250 property requirement only for Black voters (1821), and Pennsylvania barred Black men from voting entirely (1838). Women could not vote, and New Jersey, which had let some women and free Black men vote, ended that in 1807.
- Increased Voter Turnout: From 350,000 in 1824 to 2.4 million in 1840.
Political Parties:
- Nominating Conventions: Replaced caucuses, allowing more popular participation.
- Popular Election of Electors: By 1832, all states except South Carolina allowed voters to choose presidential electors.
- Two-Party System: Emerged to organize national campaigns.
- Second Party System: By the mid-1830s, the Democrats (led by Andrew Jackson) and the Whigs (led by Henry Clay) competed in nearly every state. Parties built local organizations, ran newspapers, and held rallies to win the new mass of voters, and turnout reached about 80 percent of eligible voters in 1840 (see 4.7).
Third Parties:
- Anti-Masonic Party and Workingmen’s Party: Addressed issues neglected by major parties, like secret societies and labor rights.
More Elected Offices:
- Increased Voter Participation: More state and local officials were elected, involving voters more directly in government.
Popular Campaigning:
- Targeting Common People: Campaigns featured parades, rallies, and free food, appealing to ordinary citizens.
- Negative Campaigning: Candidates often attacked opponents personally rather than discussing issues.
Spoils System and Rotation of Officeholders:
- Jackson's Policies: Appointed loyal Democrats to federal jobs, replacing non-Democrats.
- Rotation in Office: Limited terms to allow more citizens to serve in government.
- Democratic Ideals: Affirmed the belief that ordinary Americans could hold government office, strengthening the two-party system.
- Effects of the Expansion: Politics became more democratic for white men, and parties and candidates now had to appeal directly to ordinary voters. Andrew Jackson rode this new mass politics to the White House as the champion of the "common man." But the same years narrowed rights for free Black men and left women outside politics entirely, which helped spark the abolition and women's rights movements (see 4.10).
Practice exam
Test yourself on Unit 4: New Republic (1800 - 1848)
Three exams for this unit in the real AP format, timed, with your score and what to study next.