Dove's LibraryDove's Library

7.1 - Imperialism: Debates

Seward and Alaska
  • William H. Seward, as Secretary of State, played a crucial role in expanding U.S. territory by purchasing Alaska from Russia in 1867 for $7.2 million. Though initially mocked as "Seward’s Folly," the acquisition proved valuable due to its resources.
Hawaiian Islands
  • American settlers and missionaries had established a significant presence in Hawaii by the late 19th century. In 1893, American settlers aided in overthrowing the Hawaiian monarchy, seeking annexation by the U.S. to avoid tariffs on sugar, but President Grover Cleveland opposed annexation due to his anti-imperialist stance.
    • Annexation (1898): Queen Liliuokalani protested to Washington, and Hawaii stayed an independent republic run by the planters until Cleveland left office (see 6.5 for why the planters wanted annexation). Under McKinley, Congress annexed Hawaii in July 1898 with a joint resolution (the Newlands Resolution), because the Spanish-American War had made Hawaii valuable as a naval base and coaling station on the way to the Philippines. Hawaii became a U.S. territory in 1900.

New Imperialism

  • Economic Interests: The U.S. aimed to expand its markets and secure raw materials like minerals and rubber by establishing control over foreign territories.
    • Example: by the 1890s, American investors owned sugar plantations in Hawaii and Cuba and railroads and banana plantations in Central America (see 6.5). After the depression of the 1890s, many business leaders argued that American farms and factories produced more than Americans could buy, so the U.S. needed new markets overseas.
  • Political and Military Power: Influential figures like Alfred Thayer Mahan argued that a strong navy and overseas bases were essential for the U.S. to become a world power, leading to the expansion of the U.S. Navy and acquisition of strategic islands.
  • Social Fears: The economic instability of the 1890s, including the Panic of 1893, led to fears of social unrest, and overseas expansion was seen as a way to alleviate domestic pressures.
  • Darwinism and Religion: Many expansionists believed in the racial and cultural superiority of Anglo-Saxons and saw imperialism as a moral duty to spread Christianity and Western civilization.
    • Example: in his book Our Country (1885), minister Josiah Strong argued that Anglo-Saxons were a superior race chosen to spread Protestant Christianity and American institutions around the world. Ideas like these (often called Social Darwinism when applied to nations) made empire look natural and even generous to many Americans.
  • Popular Press: Sensationalist journalism fueled public interest in imperialism by glorifying the adventures and opportunities abroad.
  • The "Closed" Frontier: The 1890 census reported that the U.S. no longer had a clear frontier line, and in 1893 historian Frederick Jackson Turner argued that the frontier had shaped American democracy (see 6.2). Expansionists worried that without new land the country would lose its "safety valve" for discontent and its source of growth, so they argued that Americans were destined to expand overseas instead.
  • Competition with European Empires: In the 1880s and 1890s, European powers were dividing Africa among themselves and, along with Japan, claiming spheres of influence in China. Imperialists warned that if the U.S. did not take colonies, naval bases, and markets of its own, it would be shut out and fall behind as a second-rate power.

Opposition to Imperialism

  • Anti-imperialists argued that imperialism contradicted the principles of self-determination and democracy, as it involved ruling over others without their consent.
  • Racial theories were used on both sides. Some anti-imperialists rejected the idea of racial superiority, but many others used racial theories themselves: they argued that Filipinos, Puerto Ricans, and other nonwhite peoples could never become equal citizens, so annexing their lands would bring "inferior" peoples into the nation. Labor leaders like Samuel Gompers also feared competition from cheap colonial labor.
  • Isolationists believed that following George Washington’s advice to avoid foreign entanglements was still relevant, opposing the costs and moral implications of imperialism.
  • Critics also showed the financial burden of maintaining a large navy and controlling overseas territories, arguing that imperialism was economically unwise.
  • Anti-Imperialist League (1898): Formed to fight the annexation of the Philippines. Its supporters included writer Mark Twain, steel tycoon Andrew Carnegie, reformer Jane Addams, and labor leader Samuel Gompers, which shows that opposition to empire crossed party and class lines. They argued that ruling Filipinos without their consent betrayed the Declaration of Independence.
  • A Divided Nation: The Senate approved the Treaty of Paris, which gave the U.S. the Philippines (see 7.2), in February 1899 by a vote of 57 to 27, only one vote more than the two-thirds it needed.

Practice exam

Test yourself on Unit 7: Progressive Era and World Wars (1890 - 1945)

Three exams for this unit in the real AP format, timed, with your score and what to study next.

AP® is a registered trademark of the College Board, which is not affiliated with Dove's Library and was not involved in the production of, and does not endorse, this website.

Providing free, high-quality AP notes to help students succeed, earn college credit, and reach their educational goals, ensuring everyone has access to the resources they need.

© 2026 Standard Learning Group, Inc., which operates Dove's Library. All rights reserved.